1934 Diamond Stars Baseball Cards: Most Valuable (Top Picks)

diamond-stars-cochrane

The 1933 Goudey set gets all the fanfare for being the first card set to issue packs of cards with gum.

But the underappreciated 1934-36 Diamond Stars Baseball card set deserves more attention. 

The 108 card set covered a three year period from 1934 to 1936, offering up real competition for Goudey. 

The lack of serious collector interest likely stems from the omission of Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, contracted by Goudey at the time.

In this piece we take a closer look at the 1934-36 Diamond Stars set, showcasing the most valuable cards in the issue. 

1934-1936 Diamond Stars Baseball Card Facts

Cataloged as R327 by Jefferson Burdick in the American Card Catalog, the Diamond Stars set is an overlooked hobby masterpiece.

foxx-diamond-stars

Issued by National Chicle, a gum company based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, which also produced the 1934-36 'Batter Up' (R318) set

cronin-batter-up

A 1934-36 Batter Up R318 Card of Joe Cronin

One baseball card was found in each one cent Diamond Stars pack, along with a piece of gum.

The design on the front of the pack is reminiscent of the 'art-deco' design used on the cards themselves. 

Here we see a bright yellow background with a massive red star along with a player illustration. I'm not sure if it's an actual player (but we can see Cleveland on the jersey). There were eight different wrapper variations

diamond-stars-wrapper

A wrapper from the 1934-1936 National Chicle Diamond Stars set

National Chicle also offered fans the chance to exchange 15 Diamond Star wrappers for an oversized (5" x 8") photo card. This was similar to what Goudey had done in 1933, although Goudey required kids to mail in the wrappers

The Diamond Stars wrapper alluded to 50 'photographic art pictures'. Yet, there are only 43 known National Chicle Premiums (R311) issued for baseball players

r311-traynor

A 1934-36 R311 National Chicle Premium card of Pie Traynor.

The 1934-1936 Diamond Stars cards were issued continuously over three years. The cards are well known for their unique, colorful designs.  

The common description of the set is 'art-deco' which is known for "sleek, linear, often rectangular geometric forms, arranged and broken up by curved ornamental elements".

The card backgrounds consist of different geometrical shapes, lines, flags and colors. 

Novice collectors might not be aware of the beauty of Diamond Stars cards. But once you see all of the cards together, it's clear that National Chicle made some bold design choices. 

Case in point, is this Bill Terry card. Check out the dark outlines of big buildings in the background and colorful shapes to accent the scene

bill-terry-diamond-stars

Interesting Tidbits On The 1934-1936 R327 Diamond Stars Set

1. The cards were issued over three years and National Chicle made updates to player stats or team changes on the back of the card along the way.

Thus, with all the different variations, the 108 card set balloons to a total of 170 cards. 

2. There are only 96 players that appear in the 108 card Diamond Stars set

Cards 97 through 108 are of players that already appeared in card numbers 1 through 96. 

3. Card Backs printed with either green or blue Text

Trying to identify when a Diamond Stars card was printed might be one of the most confusing parts about this set.

Old Cardboard has a good checklist that details years and back colors.

Here are two backs of #9 Mickey Cochrane.  

Green backs were printed in both 1934 and 1935 so text coloring is not the giveaway.

Cards printed in 1934 are harder to find than the other two years and do carry a slight premium.

In the case of the first Cochrane, if you read the stats, we see it is referencing stats from 1934 so it is a 1935 issue.

The blue text Cochrane references stats from 1935, thus it is considered a 1936 issue. 

1935 Diamond Stars Cochrane with a Green Back

cochrane-blue-back

1936 Diamond Stars Cochrane with Blue Back

4. Card backs offered baseball tips for kids.

The player stats are sparse, but Diamond Kings offers a very lengthy writeup, offering kids different baseball tips. In the case of the Cochrane, we can see it discusses 'The Catcher's Throw'. 

Note the tip corresponds with the player's position. The tips were authored by Austen Lake, a writer for the Boston American, who was well known for his negative writings about Sox slugger Ted Williams

5. There Are Two Popular Error Cards In The Set

Card #36 of Ernie Lombardi is misspelled 'Earnie' on the back of one variation.

Card #54 of Hank Greenberg is misspelled 'Greenburg' on the front of one variation. 

Both error cards are harder to find and carry a premium versus the corrected version.

1934-36 Diamond Stars Hank 'Greenburg' error card

Our Top Picks - 1935 Diamond Stars Baseball Cards

Best Overall Value: Pie Traynor #99

Best Investment Potential: Hank Greenburg Error #54

Best Overall Design: Al Lopez (#28, #97)

Most Underrated Card: Jimmie Foxx #65

1934-36 Diamond Stars Baseball Most Valuable Cards

Here are the most valuable cards in the 1934-36 Diamond Stars Baseball setwith values from the PSA SMR Price guide, using PSA 7 (Near Mint) prices as a guide.

Lower graded copies of nearly all the cards here are somewhat affordable, so piecing together a complete set is doable. 

You can buy commons in lower grades for about $10-$20 per card

But, if going after the 170 different variations in the set, completing it can be somewhat pricey. 

Note that PSA refers to the set as '1935 Diamond Stars' so we will use that from here on in.

1935 Diamond Stars Lefty Grove #1

lefty-grove-ds

Lefty Grove was one of the best left handed baseball pitchers to ever play the game, winning over 300 games during his 17 year career. 

Grove's Diamond Star #1 card is the most valuable card in the set. 

Given his HOF status and star power, the card is highly sought after, but its position as the first card in the set amplifies the value.

Cards at the #1 position were tortured by kids, stacked up, susceptible to more damage, making it very hard to find in nice condition.

There are over 200 graded copies of the Grove #1 card, so it's not as rare as the high number cards, but still pricey in higher grades.

There are two variations of the Grove card, one from 1934 (with his 1933 stats ) and one produced in 1935 (1934 stats). Both cards have green print on the backs. The Grove 1934 issued is the harder to find between the two.

A PSA 7 copy recently sold at Heritage Auctions for $9,900.

1935 Diamond Stars Hank "Greenburg" Error #54

1934-36 Diamond Stars Hank 'Greenburg' error card

National Chicle goofed on two cards in the set - the #54 Hank 'Greenburg' error card shown here is one of the two major errors in the set.

The card was later fixed (to Greenberg), yet the error card is rarer (only 90 PSA graded copies versus 415 PSA graded copies for the corrected version).

A PSA 8 Greenburg error card sold in 2021 for $5,760 at Heritage Auctions.

The corrected version of #54 "Greenberg" is also among the top ten valuable cards in the Diamond stars set. A PSA 8 copy of the corrected version sold for a little over $4,000 at a recent auction.

1935 Diamond Stars Bill Dickey #103

dickey-103

New York Yankees HOF Catcher and Manager Bill Dickey was a member of an amazing seven World Series teams as a player and another six as a manager. Bob Feller called Dickey 'the best catcher' he ever saw

Dickey has two cards in the Diamond Stars #11 and #103. Dickey's #103 card is part of a run of short printed high number cards (#97 to #108) and is incredibly hard to find in comparison to other cards in the set. 

There are only 26 PSA graded copies of Dickey's #103 Diamond Stars card, and 175 PSA graded copies of his #11 card.

Hence the reason Bill Dickey #103 is one of the most valuable cards in the set. 

1935 Diamond Stars Pie Traynor #99

pie-traynor

Traynor is one of the best third basemen in baseball history.

The "Pie" Traynor Diamond Stars #99 card is one of the short print high numbers in the set. There are less than 30 PSA graded copies, making it one of the harder to find cards in the set. 

Still, even with the scarcity, the card is affordable, with lower grade copies sometimes found for under $500. A great deal for a card of a HOF player not produced in very significant quantities. 

Note that Traynor has an identical, more widely produced card #27 that is identical to the #99 card.

1935 Diamond Stars Jimmie Foxx #65

foxx-diamond-stars

One of the greatest power hitters to play the game, the Diamond Stars card of Jimmie Foxx is a bit of an abnormality. 

While Foxx started out his career as a catcher, he played the majority of his career at first base

Over the course of this card's production (from 1934 to 1936), Foxx played only 26 games at catcher.

Hence, this one has a bit of a cult following among vintage card collectors. 

I selected the Diamond Stars Foxx card as the most underrated card in the set.  

Foxx is generally underrated as a player so this selection makes sense. Foxx was a three-time MVP and a nine-time all star game selection. He was a triple crown winner with an astounding twelve straight seasons with over 30 home runs.

1935 Diamond Stars Rogers Hornsby #44

hornsby

HOF slugger Rogers Hornsby played a remarkable 23 seasons in major league baseball. At the tail end of his career, Hornsby played little and was acting as a player/manager for the St Louis Browns.

Hornsby's card has 780 PSA graded copies, making it the card with the highest PSA graded population in the set.

1935 Diamond Stars Al Lopez #97

97-lopez

Hall Of Fame catcher Al Lopez has two cards in the Diamond Stars set (#28, #97), but it's the #97 Lopez card which is more valuable.

The Diamond Stars #97 Lopez card is a high number short print and has a fraction of the graded cards compared to his #28 card. 

I also chose the Lopez as the best design in the set. I'm a sucker for horizontal designs and the action shot is one of the highlights. 

1935 Diamond Stars Earl Averill #100

earle-averill

HOF pitcher Earl Averill has two (identical) cards in the set, #35 and #100, but the #100 is a more valuable and scarcer high number card.

There are over 400 PSA-graded copies of Averill's #35 Diamond Stars card, yet only 36 PSA-graded copies of card #100.

Thus, there is a significant price difference between the two, although mid-grade copies of #100 Averill are still relatively affordable

Side note, Earl Averill's name is misspelled 'Earle' but the error was not corrected.

1935 Diamond Stars Frankie Frisch #17

diamond-frisch

Frankie Frisch was a solid hitter, with blazing speed and great defensive abilities. The HOF second baseman was a key cog on four World Series Champion teams, including the Giants and Cardinals. 

His Diamond Stars #17 card is somewhat scarce compared to other more plentiful cards, with only ~170 PSA Graded copies. 

1935 Diamond Stars Earnie, Ernie Lombardi #36, #105

lombardi-diamond

Ernie Lombardi has two cards in the Diamond Stars set, #36 and #105.

Card #36 was misspelled 'Earnie' and later corrected. The error is much harder to find, with roughly 1/4 of the graded population (104 PSA graded error cards vs 420 PSA graded corrected versions). 

Lombardi's #105 card is a short print and actually harder to find than the error #36, with only 26 PSA graded cards in existence. 

Investment Potential Of The 1935 Diamond Stars Set

The 1934-36 Diamond Stars Baseball Card set is one of the most underrated sets of the pre war era. 

Famous for its colorful, art deco like designs, the 108 card set is filled with 35 Hall of Fame cards. 

No Ruth or Gehrig here, but there's enough HOF power to keep most vintage collectors happy.

Diamond Stars cards are an excellent investment, especially scarcer issues (such as the 'Greenburg' error) or the high number short prints.

The set also offers more affordable options of what I would call Tier 2 HOF players - guys like Kiki Cuyler, Luke Appling and Paul Waner.

High grade copies of HOFers in the set are also a very good choice for collectors looking for potential capital appreciation.

Overall Investment Rating: 7.5 out of 10


Diamond Stars Cards For Sale On eBay

1934-36 Diamond Stars Checklist

1Lefty Grove (HOF)
2Al Simmons (HOF)
3Rabbit Maranville (HOF)
4Buddy Myer
5Tom Bridges
6Max Bishop
7Lew Fonseca
8Joe Vosmik
9Mickey Cochrane (HOF)
10Roy Mahaffey
11Bill Dickey (HOF)
12Dixie Walker
13George Blaeholder
14Bill Terry (HOF)
15Dick Bartell
16Lloyd Waner (HOF)
17Frankie Frisch (HOF)
18Chick Hafey (HOF)
19Van Mungo
20Shanty Hogan
21Johnny Vergez
22Jimmy Wilson
23Bill Hallahan
24Sparky Adams
25Walter Berger
26Pepper Martin
27Pie Traynor (HOF)
28Al Lopez (HOF)
29Robert Rolfe
30Heinie Manush (HOF)
31Ki Ki Cuyler (Reds) (HOF)
31Ki Ki Cuyler (Cubs) (HOF)
32Sam Rice (HOF)
33Schoolboy Rowe
34Stanley Hack
35Earl Averill (HOF)
36Ernie Lombardi (HOF)
37Billie Urbanski
38Ben Chapman
39Carl Hubbell (HOF)
40Blondy Ryan
41Harvey Hendrick
42Jimmy Dykes
43Ted Lyons (HOF)
44Rogers Hornsby (HOF)
45Jo Jo White
46Red Lucas
47Cliff Bolton
48Rick Ferrell (HOF)
49Buck Jordan
50Mel Ott (HOF)
51John Whitehead
52George Stainback
53Oscar Melillo
54Hank Greenburg (HOF) Error
54Hank Greenberg (HOF)
55Tony Cuccinello
56Gus Suhr
57Cy Blanton
58Glenn Myatt
59Jim Bottomley (HOF)
60Red Ruffing (HOF)
61Billie Werber
62Fred Frankhouse
63Travis Jackson (HOF)
64Jimmie Foxx (HOF)
65Zeke Bonura
66Ducky Medwick (HOF)
67Marvin Owen
68Sam Leslie
69Earl Grace
70Hal Trosky
71Ossie Bleuge
72Tony Piet
73Fritz Ostermueller
74Tony Lazzeri (HOF)
75Irving Burns
76Bill Rogell
77Charlie Gehringer (HOF)
78Joe Kuhel
79Willis Hudlin
80Louis Chiozza
81Bill DeLancey
82John Babich
83Paul Waner (HOF)
84Sam Byrd
85Julius Solters
86Frank Crosetti
87Steve O'Neil
88George Selkirk
89Joe Stripp
90Ray Hayworth
91Bucky Harris (HOF)
92Ethan Allen
93Alvin Crowder
94Wes Ferrell
95Luke Appling (HOF)
96Lew Riggs
97Al Lopez (HOF)
98Schoolboy Rowe
99Pie Traynor (HOF)
100Earl Averill (HOF)
101Dick Bartell
102Van Mungo
103Bill Dickey (HOF)
104Robert Rolfe
105Ernie Lombardi (HOF)
106Red Lucas
107Stanley Hack
108Wally Berger
All Vintage Cards
 

All Vintage Cards is the number one destination for everything related to vintage baseball, basketball, hockey, and football cards. Our love of card collecting and in particular vintage sports cards drives our desire to inform others of the joys of collecting.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: