How Much Does It Cost To Build A T206 White Borders Set?
It won’t be cheap, but for collectors with a large budget, piecing together a T206 set is an achievable — if expensive — endeavor.
All Vintage Cards content is free. When you purchase through referral links on our site, we earn a commission. Learn more
The most popular pre-war tobacco card set is the 1909-1911 T206 White Borders set — known as “The Monster” for its 524-card checklist, 36 advertising backs, and the obsessive challenge it presents to set builders.
The popularity has never wavered. High-grade assembled sets have sold for $350,000 to $390,000 at major auction houses, and collector demand continues to drive prices upward across every tier of the set.
Yet for those looking to enter the T206 game, the high costs of the key HOF cards can leave budget-minded collectors out of the loop. This guide breaks down the cost to build a near-complete 520-card set — excluding the impossible four of Wagner, Plank, Magie, and Doyle — using ungraded cards in poor to good condition with common backs.
Updated for 2026: We estimate the cost to build a 520-card T206 set at approximately $100,000 — up significantly from our 2022 estimate of $65,000.
AVC Acquisitions Portal
Sell Your Card Collection
Skip the listing process and long wait times. Get a professional offer on your collection within 48 hours. See our buy list.
All prices are based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal backs unless otherwise noted. You might get lucky with some purchases, but use these estimates as a baseline guideline. See the T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values on individual cards.
T206 Set Cost Summary
| Section | Cards | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Ty Cobb (4 cards) | 4 | $21,600 |
| Cy Young (3 cards) | 3 | $6,250 |
| Christy Mathewson (3 cards) | 3 | $4,800 |
| Walter Johnson (2 cards) | 2 | $5,100 |
| Nap Lajoie (3 cards) | 3 | $2,700 |
| Tris Speaker (1 card) | 1 | $1,000 |
| Demmitt & O’Hara St. Louis | 2 | $6,000 |
| Lower/Mid Tier HOFers | 58 | $19,300 |
| Southern Leaguers | 50 | $9,250 |
| Commons | 396 | $25,740 |
| Total (520 cards) | 522 | ~$101,740 |
Top Tier T206 HOFers (16) $44,000
T206 Ty Cobb Cards (4) – Estimated Costs $22,000+
There are four Cobb cards in the set, two portrait cards (Red and Green backgrounds) and two non-portrait cards (Bat Off Shoulder and Bat On Shoulder).
The T206 Cobbs will account for a significant part of your T206 set budget; some collectors like to get this one out of the way first.
The ‘Green Portrait’ Cobb has about half of the existing PSA population compared to the Red Portrait Cobb and sells at a significant premium over the other Cobbs in the set.
Estimated PSA 2 Values For All Cobb T206 Cards
| Card | PSA 2 Value |
|---|---|
| Cobb Red Portrait | $5,000 |
| Cobb Green Portrait | $7,500 |
| Cobb Bat Off Shoulder | $4,600 |
| Cobb Bat On Shoulder | $4,500 |
| Total | $21,600 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Cy Young Cards (3) — Estimated Cost $6,000+
Cy Young has three cards in the set. His portrait card features a striking green background and is one of the most visually beautiful cards in the entire T206 set — worth targeting at PSA 2 or better, given how much the green background deteriorates in Poor condition.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 2) |
|---|---|
| Young Portrait | $2,400 |
| Young Glove Shows | $1,950 |
| Young Bare Hands | $1,900 |
| Total | $6,250 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See the T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Christy Mathewson Cards (3) — Estimated Cost $5,000+
Christy Mathewson has three cards in the T206 set. His portrait card is the most valuable and most sought-after of the three. The White Cap variation has the lowest-graded population of the three, though in practice, it trades at roughly the same level as the Dark Cap at lower grades.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 2) |
|---|---|
| Mathewson Portrait | $1,800 |
| Mathewson White Cap | $1,500 |
| Mathewson Dark Cap | $1,500 |
| Total | $4,800 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Walter Johnson Cards (2) Estimated Costs $5,000+
Walter Johnson has two cards in the T206 set — a portrait card and a Hands At Chest card. Like most players in the set, the portrait commands a significant premium over the action card. Johnson’s portrait is one of the more visually striking cards in the set and a centerpiece of any HOF subset.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 2) |
|---|---|
| Walter Johnson Portrait | $3,500 |
| Walter Johnson Hands At Chest | $1,600 |
| Total | $5,100 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Nap Lajoie Cards (3) Estimated Costs $3,000+
Nap Lajoie has three cards in the T206 set. His portrait card is the most valuable and has shown strong appreciation over the past eight years — PSA 4 copies have increased over 200% since 2018. The two action cards (Throwing and With Bat) are considerably more affordable and represent good value for set builders.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 2) |
|---|---|
| Lajoie Portrait | $1,200 |
| Lajoie Throwing | $750 |
| Lajoie With Bat | $750 |
| Total | $2,700 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See the T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Tris Speaker Estimated Cost $1000
Surprisingly, Tris Speaker has only one card in the T206 set despite being one of the era’s greatest players. At $1,000 in PSA 2 condition he’s one of the more accessible top-tier HOF cards in the set and a straightforward acquisition for most set builders.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 2) |
|---|---|
| Tris Speaker | $1,000 |
| Total | $1,000 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
The Expensive Variations: Demmitt & O’Hara — Estimated Cost $6,000
Two cards in the 520 set will catch budget-conscious collectors off guard — Ray Demmitt (St. Louis) and Bill O’Hara (St. Louis). Neither player is a Hall of Famer, but both command premium prices due to their scarcity as mid-production variations.
Both players were traded from New York to St. Louis during the T206 production run, resulting in two versions of each card. The New York versions are common and inexpensive. The St. Louis variations are significantly scarcer — and significantly more expensive.
Some collectors opt for a 518 set, skipping both St. Louis variations entirely due to the cost relative to the players’ historical significance. That’s a perfectly valid approach, but purists building a true 520 set will need to budget accordingly.
| Card | Estimated Cost (PSA 1) |
|---|---|
| Ray Demmitt (St. Louis) | $3,000 |
| Bill O’Hara (St. Louis) | $3,000 |
| Total | $6,000 |
Prices based on PSA 1 (Poor) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
Lower to Middle Tier HOFers (58) — Estimated Cost $19,300
The lower- and middle-tier HOF cards have appreciated considerably since our original 2022 estimate. Cards that once sold for $100 or less now regularly sell for $200-$600 in PSA 2 condition, with portrait cards and popular players commanding the largest premiums.
The most expensive cards in this tier are the Willie Keeler cards, Rube Waddell Portrait, Addie Joss Portrait, and Mordecai Brown cards — all running $500-$650 at PSA 2. The most affordable are the Vic Willis action cards, Clark Griffith Batting, Hugh Duffy, and Ed Walsh, at around $200 each.
| Card | PSA 2 |
|---|---|
| Willie Keeler Portrait | $640 |
| Willie Keeler Batting | $640 |
| Rube Waddell Portrait | $640 |
| Addie Joss Portrait | $584 |
| Mordecai Brown Cubs Shirt | $560 |
| Mordecai Brown Portrait | $560 |
| Rube Waddell Throwing | $536 |
| Mordecai Brown Chicago Shirt | $480 |
| Eddie Collins | $480 |
| Johnny Evers Portrait | $480 |
| Addie Joss Pitching | $480 |
| Iron Man McGinnity | $480 |
| Joe Tinker Portrait | $480 |
| Joe Tinker Hands on Knees | $400 |
| Chief Bender Portrait | $376 |
| Rube Marquard Portrait | $360 |
| Joe Tinker Bat Off | $360 |
| Joe Tinker Bat On | $360 |
| Johnny Evers Bat Chicago Shirt | $352 |
| Frank Chance Portrait Yellow | $320 |
| Jimmy Collins | $320 |
| Johnny Evers Bat Cubs Shirt | $320 |
| John McGraw Portrait No Cap | $320 |
| John McGraw Portrait Cap | $320 |
| Frank Chance Portrait Red | $312 |
| Sam Crawford Bat | $304 |
| Sam Crawford Throwing | $296 |
| Elmer Flick | $296 |
| Jack Chesbro | $288 |
| Hughie Jennings Portrait | $288 |
| John McGraw Finger In Air | $280 |
| Fred Clarke Portrait | $272 |
| Home Run Baker | $270 |
| Roger Bresnahan Portrait | $256 |
| Frank Chance Batting | $256 |
| Clark Griffith Portrait | $256 |
| Joe Kelley | $256 |
| Rube Marquard Hands Thighs | $256 |
| Rube Marquard Pitching | $256 |
| George Davis | $254 |
| Jake Beckley Portrait | $240 |
| Chief Bender Pitching Trees | $240 |
| Chief Bender Pitching No Trees | $240 |
| Fred Clarke Pitt Bat | $240 |
| Miller Huggins Portrait | $240 |
| Zack Wheat | $240 |
| Vic Willis Portrait | $240 |
| Bobby Wallace | $234 |
| Roger Bresnahan Bat | $224 |
| John McGraw Glove At Hip | $224 |
| Hughie Jennings One Hand | $216 |
| Hughie Jennings Both Hands | $216 |
| Hugh Duffy | $208 |
| Clark Griffith Batting | $208 |
| Miller Huggins Hand Mouth | $208 |
| Ed Walsh | $208 |
| Vic Willis Throwing | $208 |
| Vic Willis Bat | $208 |
| Total | $19,300 |
Prices based on PSA 2 (Good condition) with a common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal back. See T206 price guide for grade-by-grade values.
T206 Southern Leaguers (50) — Estimated Cost $9,250
Southern League cards have appreciated considerably since our original estimate. What once averaged $80 per card now runs closer to $175–$200 each in poor to good condition, reflecting increased demand from 520 set builders and the genuine scarcity of many Southern League subjects.
A few of the rarer Southern Leaguers — particularly Ed Reagan, which is more than 5x scarcer than cards with regular distribution — will cost significantly more than the average. Budget for some variance within this category.
| Category | Cards | Avg. Cost | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Southern League cards | 50 | ~$185 | $9,250 |
See T206 Southern League Checklist → for the full 50-card list. Prices vary by scarcity
T206 Commons (396) — Estimated Cost $25,000+
Common card prices have nearly doubled since our original 2022 estimate. What once averaged $35 per card now runs closer to $65 each in poor to good condition with common backs — a reflection of the broader appreciation across the T206 market over the past several years.
The good news is that commons remain the most accessible cards in the set and, with patience, can still be found at reasonable prices. Buying in bulk, attending shows, and regularly monitoring Net54 and eBay will help keep costs down in this category.
| Category | Cards | Avg. Cost | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commons (Piedmont/Sweet Cap back) | 396 | ~$65 | $25,740 |
Prices assume common Piedmont or Sweet Caporal backs in poor to good condition. Cards with scarcer backs will cost significantly more — see the T206 back multiplier guide →
Related T206 Guides
→ T206 White Borders Set: Complete Collector’s Guide →
→ How to Collect T206 Cards: 11 Approaches for Every Budget →
→ T206 Hall of Famers Guide →
→ How to Spot a Fake T206 Card →
→ T206 Price Guide →
