Mario Lemieux Rookie Card (Best Value, Investment Potential)

lemieux rcIf you were a hockey fan during the 1980s, you were lucky enough to witness some of the best hockey players ever to play the game.

Wayne Gretzky, Mark Messier, and of course the great Mario Lemieux, three players that often are discussed among the ten best hockey players of all time

In terms of hockey cards, the Mario Lemieux rookie card is right up there with the most valuable hockey cards in the hobby

Of course, Lemieux’s rookie card was released in the midst of the Junk era; thus, between his two major rookie cards (1985 Topps and O-Pee-Cee), there’s plenty of supply to go around for everyone.

In this piece, I’ll look at the two key rookie cards for Lemieux, examining the scarcity, current values, and long-term investment potential.

Mario Lemieux As A Player

Mario Lemieux was born on October 5th, 1965 in Montreal, Canada. 

He became one of the greatest hockey players of all time. 

His intense dedication to the game and hard work ethic had Lemieux positioned for greatness early on.

mario

Source - Wiki Commons

Lemieux would spend countless hours after school playing pick up hockey until the sun set. His family even bringing snow into the house so that he and his brothers could practice their skills indoors

"According to local lore, when the snow got too deep to play hockey outside. Madame Lemieux transported shovels of snow into the house. She threw the snow on the carpet and pounded it down to a smooth surface that glistened like ice. "

Mario played junior hockey with the Laval Voisins of the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League from 1981 to 1984 where he broke nearly every single junior hockey record imaginable.

In his last season with Laval, he tallied an unbelievable total of 282 points, with 133 goals and 149 assists in only 70 games!

lemieux stats

Stats/Image, courtesy EliteProspects.com

The following year the Pittsburgh Penguins drafted the 6'4", 230 pound Lemieux with their first pick overall in 1984, which turned out to be a pretty impressive draft class, including Patrick Roy, Brett Hull and Luc Robitaille. 

At the time of the 1984 Draft, Lemieux was the clear cut consensus #1 pick, however some critiqued his lack of mobility and bad shape (Lemieux was not shy when it came to fast food). 

Those fears would go unfounded, as Lemieux soon became the savior for Pittsburgh they expected him to be, practically saving a near bankrupt team from its own demise.

"Super Mario" played his entire seventeen year career with the Penguins, leading the team to Stanley Cup victories, and winning multiple awards including three Hart Trophies and six Art Ross Trophies. 

"At the age of 6, I knew he'd play professionally. He was playing mite hockey with boys who were 9 or 10 years old and he was already the leader of the team.”


-Jean-Guy Lemieux (Mario's Dad) (source)

Lemieux did have a major scare in 1992, when he was diagnosed with Hodgkin lymphoma, a dangerous, but treatable cancer, considering that it was found early.

Due to radiation treatments, Lemieux missed two months of the 1992-93 season. Following back surgery the next year, Lemieux announced a leave of absence from hockey, seeing him miss a significant portion of the 93-94 season, and the entire 94-95 season.

Thankfully, Lemieux's cancer was in remission and he returned to play in 1995-96, achieving his third best career point total for the season, marking one of the best comebacks in the history of sports.  

Lemieux retired at the age of 31 in 1997 and was inducted into Hockey Hall of Fame that same year. He would end up buying the Pittsburgh Penguins in 1999, later returning to the ice from 2000-2006.

Mario Lemieux Rookie Card - 1985 Topps #9, 1985 O-Pee-Chee #9

Mario Lemieux has two key rookie cards: 1985 Topps #9 and 1985 O-Pee-Chee #9. 

The 1985 Topps hockey cards were distributed in the US, whereas the O-Pee-Chee, or Canadian version were distributed in Canada.

The fronts of the two Lemieux rookie cards are identical, however the back of the O-Pee-Chee Lemieux rookie card features French text.

The cards feature white borders, with a full color photo of Lemieux.

The 1985 Topps and OPC hockey cards used different background colors to color coordinate with the team colors for the player’s name.

lemieux rc

The backs of the Lemieux cards are where there is a noticeable difference. As is common throughout all O-Pee-Chee sets, the OPC Lemieux back has a brighter card stock as compared to the Topps card, which is easily noticeable if comparing the backs of the cards.

lemieux-topps-back

Back of a Topps Lemieux rookie card

lemieux-opc

Back of an OPC Lemieux rookie card

The OPC Lemieux card back also has both an English and French player summary,  along with other French abbreviations. 

Mario Lemieux Rookie Card Values

A PSA 10 (Gem Mint) Topps Lemieux rookie card recently sold for over $21K, which appears somewhat reasonable, given that there are only 76 copies in existence. PSA 10 OPC Lemieux rookies are a bit harder to find with only 48 in existence, hence the massive premium at auction which saw a PSA 10 OPC Lemieux sell for over $51K. 

Based on recent sales data from PSA, Lemieux's O-Pee-Chee rookie card sells for an average 43% premium versus the Topps rookie card. I do not think this premium is warranted, given that the graded population of each card is nearly identical (see next section on population reports of Lemieux's rookie card).  

Grade
O-Pee-Chee
Topps
Premium
GEM - MT 10
59.30%
MINT 9
75.74%
NM - MT 8
62.70%
NM 7
63.29%
EX - MT 6
57.03%
EX 5
-7.86%
VG - EX 4
44.44%
VG 3
-11.25%
Avg Premium
43%

If you're wondering whether or not to get your Mario Lemieux rookie card graded, I advise you to examine the potential grade of the card and use our sports card grading calculator to see if its worth grading.  

In many cases, it might not be worth grading unless the condition is super sharp. Notably, even the value increase of a graded Topps Lemieux in EX-MT condition would be nearly entirely eaten up by grading costs.

Remember that getting a PSA 10 on any card is nearly impossible

Mario Lemieux Rookie Card - PSA Population Reports

Most believe that O-Pee-Chee cards, in general, have a lower distribution than a sister Topps set, however, I'm not sure that's always true, especially with hockey sets, where there is typically more fan interest in Canada as compared to the US.

And the population stats from PSA tell us that both Lemieux's Topps and O-Pee-Chee 1985 rookie cards has been graded at nearly an identical amount. PSA has graded roughly 4700 O-Pee-Chee Lemieux Rookie cards, and about 4800 Topps Lemieux rookie cards.

I think most collectors are surprised by this, especially given that the O-Pee-Chee Lemieux trades at a premium.

On the higher grades, specifically, from PSA 8 to PSA 10, the Lemieux OPC rookie card is a bit rarer, but from PSA 7 and below, the reverse is true.

1985 Mario Lemieux PSA Graded Population

Grade
OPC Pop
Topps Pop
GEM - MT 10
MINT 9
NM - MT 8
NM 7
EX - MT 6
EX 5
VG - EX 4
VG 3
GOOD 2
FR 1.5
PR 1
Auth

Mario Lemieux Rookie Card Investment Potential

I consider the Lemieux rookie card to be one of the best investments in all of vintage hockey cards, however, the fairly abundant supply does have me temper my expectations slightly. I named the OPC Lemieux rookie card to our All Vintage Large Cap Hockey Portfolio

For collectors looking to invest in a Lemieux, it of course, starts with affordability, but I think the PSA 9 Topps (Mint) Lemieux is the best investment at the moment, with average prices running for less than $1000, roughly 1/3 the price of the PSA OPC Lemieux.  

There are 954 PSA 9 Topps Lemieux's, so it's not a huge, huge population. I think this one should do very well over the long term. 

Overall Investment Potential: 8.5 out of 10 

1985 topps hockey - mario lemieux rookie/rc - SGC 8 nm/mint - nice centering!

$399.00  
End Date: Sunday Jan-02-2022 09:32:36 EST
Buy It Now for only: $399.00
Buy It Now

1985-86 Topps Hockey #9 Mario Lemieux Rookie Card SGC 6

$300.00  
End Date: Sunday Jan-02-2022 09:28:47 EST
Buy It Now for only: $300.00
Buy It Now

Mario Lemieux Rookie ! TOPPS 8 NM-MT Nice Higher Grade ! 1985-86 Brilliant!!!!

$100.00  
End Date: Wednesday Dec-08-2021 22:36:19 EST
Buy It Now for only: $100.00
Buy It Now

Mario Lemieux signed Rookie card TOPPS autographed 10 rare 1985-86 RC

$43.00  (6 bids)
End Date: Saturday Dec-11-2021 21:57:00 EST

Bid

1985 TOPPS #9 MARIO LEMIEUX RC PENGUINS HOF PSA 7 A3234796-688

$78.00  (10 bids)
End Date: Wednesday Dec-08-2021 21:16:37 EST

Bid

1985-86 Topps #9 Mario Lemieux Rookie RC SGC - 88 - NM/MT 8

$100.00  
End Date: Wednesday Dec-08-2021 09:24:27 EST
Buy It Now for only: $100.00
Buy It Now

1985-86 Topps Complete Set 165 (Mario Lemieux Rookie) High Grade

$1,000.00  
End Date: Saturday Jan-01-2022 00:02:11 EST
Buy It Now for only: $1,000.00
Buy It Now

1985-86 Topps Hockey #9 Mario Lemieux Penguins RC Rookie HOF SGC 8.5 NM-MT+

$202.50  (11 bids)
End Date: Tuesday Dec-07-2021 22:05:57 EST

Bid

1985 TOPPS MARIO LEMIEUX ROOKIE # 9 PSA 6

$299.95  
End Date: Tuesday Dec-07-2021 22:00:27 EST
Buy It Now for only: $299.95
Buy It Now

THE HIGHLAND MINT 1985 TOPPS ROOKIE ~MARIO LEMIEUX~ BRONZE CARD #638 OF 5000!

$224.95  
End Date: Thursday Dec-30-2021 19:46:40 EST
Buy It Now for only: $224.95
Buy It Now
All Vintage Cards
 

All Vintage Cards is the number one destination for everything related to vintage baseball, basketball, hockey, and football cards. Our love of card collecting and in particular vintage sports cards drives our desire to inform others of the joys of collecting.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: