The Best Places To Sell Your Old Sports Cards For Top Dollar

November 12, 2022

best-places-sell-cards

Has your old sports card collection been collecting dust in a closet?

If so, it's time to get rid of them and make some extra cash in the process!

Today, there are many options for collectors to sell sports cards online or offline. 

I've had decades of experience buying and selling sports cards, so this guide will help you avoid some of the same mistakes I have made in the past. 

More...

Top Places To Sell Your Sports Cards

Below, I've listed the top 12 best places to sell sports cards for top dollar.

So gather up those cards and read on for the best tips.  

1. eBay

ebay-marketplace

First up: eBay. If you're looking for a place to sell your sports cards and get top dollar, then eBay is where you want to look first.

With over 130 million active users, finding someone who will pay top dollar for your sports cards is easy.

eBay is the easiest and most effective way to sell your cards due to the massive number of users that visit the platform daily.

eBay's mobile app has come a long way in recent years; thus, a listing can be live on the platform within minutes.

The key to success on eBay is building and maintaining good feedback.

The tricky part is that everyone starts at a feedback of zero. So, if you plan to sell many cards, I would slowly build up your feedback by selling smaller items first.

The negatives for eBay are that they take a 12.9% final value fee for any sale amount up to $7500. It's a high fee but well worth it, considering eBay's large audience.

Pros:

  • Largest, most liquid online marketplace
  • Earn Top Dollar In Market
  • Can Send Discounts To Users Watching Your Listings 

Cons:

  • High fees, on average 13% of final sale price
  • Need to build up feedback to improve sell through of cards
  • No Ability To Build Brand Off eBay

2. Auction Houses

wagner-w600

A W600 Wagner recently sold at the REA Spring Auction

An auction house can be a great option if you have a highly valued sports card collection. Most auction house sales today are completed online, although some have combined in-person and online auctions.

The benefits of working with an auction house are that they handle all steps of the selling process for you. Some good ones will also help you grade certain cards if it makes sense.

The costs of working with an auction house will vary depending on what you have to sell. Auction houses often charge sellers a commission fee; however, if the card is likely to attract attention, the auctioneer might offer the seller a 'no fee' commission sale.

If you are considering the auction route, please speak to a minimum of three auction houses. Ask about the commission rate, when you will get paid following auction completion, and what advertising they do to attract buyers.

Pros:

  • Low Effort
  • Loyal collector audience with buying intent
  • Can sometimes get a portion of buyer's premium on a high demand, rare card

Cons:

  • Some auction house fees can be fairly high
  • Many auction houses bulk sell lots, earning lower value
  • Sales price is unknown until auction is complete

3. Online Card Dealers

all-vintage-shop

There are plenty of online card dealers that buy cards from collectors to resell online. All Vintage Cards (this website) is an online card dealer. Thus we are constantly buying cards from collectors

I can provide perspective from an online dealer's point of view. We typically offer around 75% of what we believe we can sell a card at retail.

Pricing can vary based on how long it might take to sell something. A low-demand card probably will earn a lower return. Bulk collections are usually also bought at a higher discount, based on the time it takes to sort, organize and realize value for the cards.

The negatives to working with an online dealer are that you don't receive the card's total value. The positives are that you know the amount you will receive, and the transaction usually happens quickly. 

In our case, a client will mail us cards. We review and send payment on the same day of receipt. 

We compete with many online dealers, but there are many that have a great reputation, including Dean's Cards, Kruk Cards and Dave & Adams Card World

Pros:

  • No Need To Visit Store, Quick Transaction
  • No Fees Involved
  • Realized sales price is known

Cons:

  • Value realized typically lower than eBay or auction house
  • Typically requires mailing out cards, which entails some risk if not insured

4. Local Card Stores

george-peps

George Pep's Card Store Quincy Massachusetts

If you don't feel like mailing your cards to an online dealer, there are still plenty of local card stores that purchase baseball cards

The key, of course, is finding a trustworthy card shop.

I encourage anyone considering working with a local dealer to look up any reviews on Google and Facebook. 

I've worked with many collectors who have been taken advantage of by local sports card dealers. So, be careful and do your homework.

Visiting a local card show is also an option and nowadays there are more and more popping up. This can be a good way to visit multiple dealers at once to see if you can arrive at a best offer. 

Pros:

  • Don't need to mail cards, can bring them to the store
  • No Fees Involved
  • Realized sales price is known

Cons:

  • Value realized typically lower than eBay or auction house
  • Some dealers have been known to take advantage of sellers

5. Net54 Buy/Sell/Trade Forums

net54forums

I've found some great deals as a buyer on the Net54 Buy/Sell/Trade forums. Most cards listed are vintage, but there are also several areas for more modern graded card sales. 

As a seller, it can be a bit intimidating since there is no personal information for the buyers (or sellers). I recommend looking back through a person's posts to look at their activity. They are likely reputable buyers and sellers if they have been around for a while. 

Importantly, Net54 has seen an influx of scammers, so use your best instincts before completing a significant deal. 

Be sure to use Paypal Goods and Services for added protection.

Pros:

  • No Middle man
  • Earn near full value for cards
  • Ability to negotiate directly

Cons:

  • Risk of scammers on the forum
  • Limited profile data masks identity of other party 

6. Blowout Cards Buy/Sell/Trade Forums

blowout-buy-sell

Like the Net54 Buy Sell Trade forums, Blowout Cards also has its own collector marketplace. It is more modern-focused, although there is a small contingency of vintage buyers and sellers. 

Many power users will provide a link to their eBay profiles, which can help confirm their identity. As with Net54, be sure to use PayPal Goods & Services as payment, which protects the Buyer and Seller.

There is a 3% fee for PayPal G&S, but it is well worth it. It is not allowed to ask a buyer to pay with PayPal F&F (no cost) at Blowout Forums.

Pros:

  • No Middle man
  • Earn near full value for cards
  • Ability to negotiate directly

Cons:

  • Risk of scammers on the forum
  • Limited profile data masks identity of other party 

7. PSA Card Forum Buy/Sell/Trade

psa-forum

There's a vibrant community of sellers over at the PSA aka Collector's Universe Forums. Membership to the forums is free and there's also an Autograph Buy/Sell/Trade forum as well.

The only reason I prefer Net54 or Blowout is for the fact that the PSA forums aren't categorized by sport or era, making it hard for a potential buyer to search. As a seller, I'm sure there's the possibility of selling at the PSA forums, but I haven't tried it yet. 

8. Facebook Groups

groups-fb

Some of my best purchases and graded card sales have happened through Facebook Groups. The key is to find the groups that most apply to what you're buying or selling. 

There are groups for each sport (Baseball Cards, Basketball Cards, Football Cards, Hockey Cards), groups for different sets, groups for different eras (Pre-War, Tobacco, etc.), and groups for sports memorabilia and even autographs. 

However, if you recently inherited a collection and want to sell a bunch of cards, there are better methods than FB Groups. Most FB groups are private and based on trust. Some will only let you join if another member recommends you. 

But, if you're in this for the long game and want to find good groups to sell cards at no fees, FB Groups can be a great option. 

Pros:

  • No Fees
  • Good ability to see someone's profile. Easy to get vouches
  • Ability to negotiate directly and sell for a known price

Cons:

  • Scammers still exist here
  • Need to deal with shipping and any repercussions if item is lost somehow

9. Facebook Marketplace

fb-marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is also a good option for selling cards. FB Marketplace offers the ability to sell to local parties or advertise your cards to a broader audience that requires shipment.

If sold locally, FB does not collect a fee but does if you sell it to someone where the transaction is not a local meetup. I recommend using something other than FB Marketplace for any cards of significant value. Meeting someone, you don't know for a transaction like this brings about many risks.

If you decide to make a deal with someone locally, I highly recommend meeting someone at your local police station. Most have a meeting spot where buyers and sellers can make a deal safely.

10. COMC

comc

COMC provides a unique model in which collectors send their cards to COMC, which handles all of the selling and fulfillment of the cards. Cards are then listed at COMC.com and on their account at eBay.

COMC's fees can be confusing, but based on the level of service you desire, there is a fixed per-card transaction fee (average of $0.50-$1) plus an additional 5% fee on the final value of the card sold. If you decide to cash out from COMC, there is an extra 10% cash-out fee.

Pros:

  • No work required
  • Ability to store cards with COMC  for a small fee
  • Buyers can ship cards to their COMC account

Cons:

  • Higher fees than eBay if trying to cash out
  • Long turnaround times are a big complaint
  • Poor picture quality

11. MySlabs

myslabs

MySlabs.com is a newer entrant to the space but has been gaining in popularity in recent years. MySlabs.com allows collectors to upload images of cards and lists on their website.

Sellers pay only a $1 listing fee and a 1% final value fee for slabbed cards. Raw cards get assessed at a 3% fee. Since PayPal handles payments, there is also a 3% processing fee for PayPal Goods and Services.

Overall, MySlabs is a very cost-effective method for those that have mostly graded cards. After processing costs, the total 4% fee is well below eBay and COMC.

Pros:

  • Low Fees
  • Quick Payment
  • No returns, means limited headaches for sellers

Cons:

  • Limited reach as compared to eBay
  • Need to handle all fulfillment

All Vintage Cards

About the author

All Vintage Cards is the number one destination for everything related to vintage baseball, basketball, hockey, and football cards. Our love of card collecting and in particular vintage sports cards drives our desire to inform others of the joys of collecting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Looking To Sell Your Collection?